Wednesday, February 14, 2024
HomeMust ReadWhich Mattress Is Better Spring Or Foam

Which Mattress Is Better Spring Or Foam

Does Your Mattress Come With A Guarantee

Which is better? foam mattresses vs. spring mattresses

High-quality, high-density mattresses should come with a 10-year guarantee.

But, some cheaper mattresses may only come with a 5-year warranty.

This doesn’t mean it’s a mattress, but it does mean that it may deteriorate more quickly.

Some mattress brands also offer quite strict guarantee conditions.

Eve, for example, requires you to unpack your mattress within one month of receiving it!

Is A Memory Foam Or Spring Mattress Better For Your Health

Theres another factor which you might want to dismiss or worry about, depending on your approach to life. This article by WebMD suggests your body heat whilst sleeping may trigger the release of potentially harmful chemicals from your mattress. It suggests that its more of an issue with foam mattresses. They said: These Volatile Organic Compounds come mainly from the polyurethane used in the mattress, but also from other chemicals used in flame retardants and plastics.

It later says that its less of an issue in the natural materials which you tend to find in expensive pocket sprung mattresses . However, it also says that The estimated doses of most VOCs remained well below the levels that could cause health effects. However, some compounds did reach levels of concern for infants and young children.

Advantages & Disadvantages Of A Foam Mattress

Polyutherene foam can contain chemicals that are unsafe for prolonged human use so it is important to look for polyutherene foam mattresses that have environmental certifications like Koala.

The Koala Mattress has undergone numerous tests to ensure it is safe to sleep on, is comfortable, and supportive to sleep on, and will last. Koalas foam is made with formulations that enhance the breathability of the comfort layer for optimal air flow, and forms around your body without prolonged mattress indentations found in memory foam or latex mattresses.

As it is designed, and built in Sydney, the Koala Mattress foam has undergone, and received Good Environmental Choice Label .

GECA is the Australian authority for assessing, testing and independently auditing products, materials and services for the Australian market. The Koala mattress has been laboratory tested to not contain any heavy metals, formaldehyde, VOCS, or hazardous materials that are potentially allergenic, carcinogenic or disruptive to hormone systems.

For safety, the foam is CETEC certificated to mean the Green Building Council of Australias standards for total volatile organic compound emission rates. The full breakdown of what standards the Koala mattress foam is certified to abide by can be found here.

Recommended Reading: How To Return My Pillow Mattress Topper

Disadvantages Of Spring Mattresses

For all that, spring mattresses are not perfect and have disadvantages:

  • In the case of continuous coil mattresses, if your bed partner moves, youll feel it. Therefore, if you want true sleeping independence, avoid them.

  • Theyre heavy, which makes their installation and maintenance more difficult if you want to air them or wash them outside.

  • If the mattress layers are made of wool or fibers, they can quickly become a breeding ground for allergens such as dust mites.

  • Because of that, if you want to keep your spring mattress clean and avoid allergies, youll need to wash it more frequently.

Confused About What’s Comfiest For A Cosy Nights Sleep Heres How To Make The Right Choice

Royal Comfort Ergopedic Latex Pocket Spring Foam Mattress ...

Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile

The mattress industry is booming and it seems as if every month a new company appears out of nowhere promising to give you the best nights sleep. With so much noise in the mattress industry, how do you choose the one that is best for you?

Among consumers, there are two types of mattresses that stand out: pocket sprung and memory foam. At first glance these two mattresses provide the best comfort, support and quality on the market, and it seems you would be hard-pressed to find a better option out there. However, there are a few key differences between pocket sprung and memory foam mattresses and knowing what these are is crucial in helping you choose the one thats right for you.

Recommended Reading: Mattress Firm Cancellation Policy

Which Is Better For You

Ultimately, choosing the right bed for you involves a lot more than just picking between foam and spring. There are high quality, comfortable and supportive mattresses of both types available so in the end, its more about picking the right mattress model.

With that said, there are a few last things to consider.

Most people will be happy with a high-quality foam mattress. Foam provides a great middle-ground by offering a supportive and pressure-relieving fit, while also feeling soft and comfortable. Side sleepers, in particular, tend to prefer foam beds, as they often do a better job of conforming to the shape of the body.

People who tend to sleep hot at night may wish to opt for a spring mattress. Innerspring beds offer far better airflow, which helps to keep the bed cool at night.

Sleepers who are heavy or sleep on their stomachs should opt for either innerspring, hybrid, or very firm foam beds, in order to get enough support. Softer foam models will likely sink too much to feel comfortable for these sleepers.

Most online mattress retailers now offer free trial periods, where you can test the bed for up to several months. If youre unsure about a mattress, this flexibility may provide a little reassurance during the purchase process.

  • Was this article helpful?

Memory Foam Feels A Bit Strange

The next chapter in the memory foam or spring mattress debate might sound a little nutty.

Some people find that memory foam feels like they are sinking into quicksand, which is a bit unnerving.

Pocket springs dont tend to give that sinking feeling. Its also easier to toss and turn in the night with a pocket spring mattress. So, if youre a fidget Bridget then you might find memory foam hard work.

You May Like: What Kind Of Mattress Does Drury Inn Use

Memory Foam Cushions & Conforms

Sleepers love memory foam for its comforting feel. It cushions pressure points like the hips and neck, relieving pain. Memory foam is excellent for side sleepers due to its excellent conformity. On the other hand, Spring mattresses lack conformed support, which may lead to pressure formation in petite sleepers.

Back Pain Relief/spinal Alignment

Are Foam Mattresses Better Than Spring Mattresses?

Poorly fitting mattresses can cause back pain and can even worsen existing aches. It is an important factor to choose a mattress that aligns properly with your spine and alleviates back pain.

Spring mattresses can be used to relieve back pain, particularly those with pocketed coils. Some spring units can offer less support or increase pain.

Spring mattresses are the most supportive for stomach and back sleepers, as they provide firm support.

Foam mattresses relieve back pain. The foam layers provide continuous support and help maintain healthy spine alignment.

Foams are great for relieving back pain because they cushion your spine arch and relieve pressure. Some foams, however, can make your back hurt more by sinking into the mattress.

Recommended Reading: What To Do With Purple Mattress Bag

But First What Do You Need To Look For In A Mattress

All a mattress needs is to be supportive, and comfortable to sleep on.

Comfort is most likely the first thing you feel when laying on a mattress, and refers to how the mattress feels when you lie down on it.

Support refers to how well your mattress is able to promote the bodys correct spinal alignment.

You see, our spine is comprised of three natural curves: the top c-shaped curve of the neck , the reverse c-shaped of the upper back , and the c-shaped curve of the lower back .

A good mattress needs to promote correct spinal alignment which means it provides adequate support to all three curves.

If the mattress is too firm, it will push on those main pressure points and take you out of alignment. If its too soft, those pressure points wont be properly supported, so your whole body flops back. said Arya Nick Shamie, MD, associate professor of orthopedic surgery and neurosurgery at Santa Monica UCLA Medical Center.

Are Memory Foam Mattresses Better Than Spring Mattress

Memory foam mattresses tend to have the highest customer stratification ratings due to their ability to provide support and pressure relief. However, the best type of bed for you will depend on your personal preferences. You will want to consider your sleep position and any health issues when deciding on a new mattress.

Take some time to research the mattress and understand how it will fit your needs. Mattress reviews found on Amazon and the brands website can also be a great way to learn more about a mattress. These reviews are written by customers who have experienced the comfort of the bed first hand. Their feedback will give you an unbiased perspective on the overall quality of the bed.

About the author

Don’t Miss: Purple Mattress Payments

What The Science Says About Sleeping On A Memory Foam Or Spring Mattress

Some research has been carried out into whether you sleep better on a memory foam mattress or a sprung mattress. One study worth discussing was called Comparative Effects of Sleep on a Standard Mattress to an Experimental Foam Surface on Sleep Architecture and CAP Rates which was published in 1997 by Scharf, Stover et al. The study refers to innerspring mattresses, which is the name for a sprung mattress in the USA.

The study explored the CAP rate which is the cyclic alternating pattern and relates to patterns of how we sleep. In summary, poor sleep is often associated with elevated CAP rates.

Researchers enlisted 10 participants and got them to spend several nights of an experimental foam surface and on a high quality innerspring hospital mattress.

The study found no differences in sleep stages, number of wakes, or total sleep time between the two conditions. However, they did find that CAP rates were significantly reduced on the foam surface. That should be seen as a victory for the foam mattress in the memory foam or spring mattress argument.

Spring Mattress Has Strong Edge Support

Better Homes &  Gardens 10 Inch Gel Memory Foam iCoil ...

The inter-connected coil structure in spring mattresses leads to stable edge support. The structural integrity along its perimeter makes spring mattress safe for the elderly and kids. Memory foam mattresses lack edge support because it compresses quickly under pressure and takes a little while to return back to its original shape.

Recommended Reading: Mattress Firm Cancel Order

A Comprehensive Comparison Of Coir Spring And Memory Foam

9/2/2019 · Theres no bounce like spring mattresses so if you or your partner move or get up, and you wont disturb each other. Another advantage of memory foam is that its hypoallergenic. The high foam density prevents dust mites from burrowing in and triggering allergy attacks that can ruin sleep. Such mattresses are also low-maintenance. They only need to be

Coil Vs Foam Mattresses Which One Is The Better Choice

It is important for your body and mind to get a good nights sleep. Sleep is essential for your health and choosing a mattress that fits your bodys needs and sleeping patterns. When it comes to picking out a mattress it is always good to figure out a budget and add some factors into your decision-making process. Knowing your options when it comes to foam vs coil is just as important.

Mattresses come in a range firm and plush options. Some are even become high-tech and mechanically operated using remote controls. Are you a side, back, or stomach sleeper? Certain mattresses accommodate certain sleeping styles. If you suffer from any mobility issues, there are specially designed mattresses to help make your life easier.

It is also important to set a budget before shopping. Some mattresses can range from under $500 dollar to $1500 dollars. Do not be afraid to try out different mattress stores. In fact, test as many mattresses as you can. Also, do not be afraid to negotiate prices with salespeople. There is a strong difference between coil mattresses and foam mattresses, and today we will look at both.

Also Check: Can You Finance A Purple Mattress

Pros And Cons Of Memory Foam Mattresses

In the debate of memory foam vs. spring mattresses, there are points to be made on all sides. If you need a short list of the benefits and potential pitfalls of memory foam, weve got you covered.


  • Memory foam fully contours to your body shape. No matter your weight or size, the foam will change itself to hug your curves.
  • Foam can bring real pain relief. Because it conforms to your specific needs, your pain points are treated more tenderly than usual.
  • Memory foam mattresses have a long lifespan. Since they dont droop over time, you can usually get more life out of a memory foam mattress than a spring one.
  • Quality foam pulls heat away. Copper-infused memory foam will serve as a type of heat magnet, pulling excess heat away from your body as you sleep.


  • Bad memory foam can be hot. If you buy a low-quality memory foam mattress, you may notice your heat is not drawn away, but rather stays near the top.
  • It can take time to adjust to foam. If youve been sleeping on a spring mattress your whole life, it might take a few weeks to get used to the different feel and support of foam.

Pocket Spring Vs Memory Foam: Which Is Better

Foam Vs. Spring Mattress – What’s the difference?

Pocket spring mattresses and memory foam mattresses have both been around for a while now as alternatives to standard innerspring mattresses. While the two mattress types do offer some similarities, there are some very important differences to consider before choosing one over the other.

Whats inside

The first and most obvious difference between a pocket spring mattress and a memory foam mattress is what they are made of.

Pocket spring mattresses are made up of hundreds of individual tempered springs, standing upright inside individual sleeves or pockets. Layers of comfort foam padding sit on top of this spring system, making for a comfortable, supportive mattress.

Memory foam mattresses, on the other hand, are made up of treated polyurethane foam. The foam is dense, and absorbs energy and body weight very well.

Who they help

Another difference to consider is what type of sleeper you are and how each bed may help you. Both mattresses offer firm, supportive options for many sleeping needs, but differ in how this support feels while sleeping.

Pocket spring mattresses are great for people who like supportive mattresses with a more firm feeling to them. The springs have a lot of positive response, and feel like they hold you up more than many other mattress types.

How long they last


Motion transfer

Don’t Miss: What To Do With Purple Mattress Bag

What Are Spring Mattresses

Spring mattresses are exactly what they sound like. These mattresses are constructed with a series of spring mattresses that provide support to the sleeper of the mattress. The top layer or the comfort layer of the spring mattress can be made from any type of foam including memory foam which provides an added layer of comfort and support to the lumbar. Spring mattresses are a little less costly than other types of mattresses and they might also be suitable for everyone since the pressure points are very distinctive.

One of the best parts about these mattresses is that they are made highly durable if their top cover and top layer are of good quality. They remain cheap but since spring can come back to its position instantly, they do not compress for a long time.

Spring mattresses are also naturally ventilated. Since there is no high density in them, the air ventilated pretty well. These mattresses are great for warm areas and hot sleepers. An additional advantage is that spring mattresses never come with an odors or chemical smells that are harmful, pungent, and a little annoying too.

Budget Memory Foam Mattresses:

Silentnight 3 Zone Memory Foam mattress

This mattress is certainly at the budget end of the scale, but it will do the job for some people. Youre getting a mattress by a brand youve heard of for a couple of hundred pounds. However, its worth noting that it is only 18cm deep and the memory foam layer makes up just 3cm of that. Most high quality mattresses are 20-30cm deep. Its also soft/medium, so its more likely to be suited to someone who is lighter than average who might not feel the benefit of a deeper mattress. Customer reviews are solid and it has won a big award.

Anyday by John Lewis Memory Foam mattress

The appealing thing about this mattress is the John Lewis & Partners brand, but lets acknowledge there are some shortfalls. Most notably, it is only 15cm deep only 2cm of that is memory foam. However, some trundle beds and bunk beds only have space for a shallow mattress, so this will fit the bill for some people. Customer reviews are good and, of course, it is sold by a trusted retailer. The seven year warranty is also much longer than I would usually expect with a budget mattress.

Don’t Miss: Can I Cancel My Mattress Firm Order

Memory Foam And Spring Comparison

Memory foam mattresses are designed to contour to your bodys shape for support and pressure relief. Memory foam mattresses are quite popular, with many reputable companies providing them as an option.

Spring mattresses are also common. This mattress type uses steel coils that pad the mattress and help distribute weight. The coils may all be connected together or individually encased to better control motion transfer.

While memory foam mattresses are a more recent addition to the mattress world, spring mattresses have been around for a long time.

There are several benefits of memory foam mattresses.

  • Theyre soft. If you want cushy, memory foam may be a good choice.
  • They mold to your body. Memory foam is famous for contouring to hug your body. It also regains its shape once you move around.
  • Theyre easy to find online. With bed-in-a-box mattresses rising in popularity, many online brands sell memory foam mattresses.
  • They provide motion isolation. Memory foam absorbs movement, which may be useful if you share your bed with a partner or pets.

There are also some drawbacks.


Most Popular